Invasive alien predator causes rapid declines of European ladybirds

Press release 2012/02 - Issued by the Centre for Ecology & Hydrology

***Strictly embargoed until 00:01am GMT, Tuesday 7th February 2012***

 

A new study provides compelling evidence that the arrival of the invasive non-native Harlequin ladybird to mainland Europe and subsequent spread has led to a rapid decline in historically-widespread species of ladybird in Britain, Belgium and Switzerland.

The analysis, published today in the scientific journal Diversity and Distributions, is further evidence that Harlequin ladybirds are displacing some native ladybirds, most probably through predation and competition. The research provides one of the first demonstrations of a strong link between the arrival of an invasive alien species and a decline in native biodiversity at a large spatial-scale.

The study was led by Dr Helen Roy from the UK’s Centre for Ecology & Hydrology and Tim Adriaens from the Research Institute for Nature and Forest (INBO) in Belgium. The research team included 20 scientists from 11 institutions located in five European countries.

Invasive alien species are internationally recognized as one of the five major drivers of biodiversity loss, but few causal relationships between their arrival in a new region and subsequent species declines have been documented in the scientific literature.

The Harlequin was first found in Belgium in 2001 and in Britain and Switzerland in 2004. Previously its arrival had been predicted to threaten native biodiversity but, until now, the effect on native species had not been quantified.

By examining thousands of ladybird distribution records (presence in a 1km2 grid cell) collected through public participatory surveys in Britain and Belgium the research team was able to show that five (Belgium) and seven (Britain) out of the eight species studied declined substantially since the arrival of the Harlequin.  One common species, the large 7-spot ladybird, has retained a stable distribution and abundance across Europe despite the arrival of the Harlequin.

A particularly dramatic decline in the 2-spot ladybird was noted, showing a decline by 30% in Belgium and 44% in Britain over the five years following the arrival of the Harlequin. Similar patterns of decline were found in ladybird abundance data (number of individuals) collated from systematic surveys of deciduous trees in Belgium, Britain and Switzerland. The 2-spot ladybird is now near the threshold of detection in habitats in which it was previously common.  The Harlequin ladybird is a deciduous tree-dwelling species and its population increase has coincided with declines in species that share the same niche.

Lead author, Dr Helen Roy of the UK’s Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, said, “This study provides strong evidence of a link between the arrival of the Harlequin ladybird and declines in other species of ladybird, a result that would not have been possible without the participation of so many members of the public gathering ladybird records across Britain, Belgium and Switzerland.”

Co-author Tim Adriaens from the Research Institute for Nature and Forest (INBO) in Belgium said, “Within the insect world ladybirds are as iconic as panda bears and they provide an incredibly useful ecological function by keeping aphids in check. At the continental scale the arrival of the Harlequin could impact on the resilience of ecosystems and severely diminish the vital services that ladybirds deliver.”

Co-author Dr Marc Kenis, from CABI Europe-Switzerland, who is leading studies on the Harlequin in Switzerland, said, “It is essential that our long-term investigations on the decline of native ladybird species are continued, as we  need to know whether this decline will persist and whether some species are at risk of local extinction. Furthermore, we need to find specific methods to better investigate the potential decline of rarer species, which were hardly noticed in our general surveys before the arrival of the invasive species.”

Co-author Dr Peter Brown, from Anglia Ruskin University, UK, said, “Long-term datasets such as those used in this work (and our recent atlas of ladybirds of Britain and Ireland) are invaluable. We are extremely grateful to the thousands of volunteer recorders who have contributed their ladybird findings to the surveys.”

Notes to Editors

Further information for journalists can be obtained from the CEH press office.

The research is published in the journal Diversity and Distributions

Full citation: Helen E. Roy(1), Tim Adriaens(2), Nick J. B. Isaac(1), Marc Kenis(3), Thierry Onkelinx(2), Gilles San Martin(4), Peter M. J. Brown(5), Louis Hautier(6,7), Remy Poland(8), David B. Roy(1), Richard Comont(1), René Eschen(3) , Robert Frost(5), Renate Zindel(3,9), Johan Van Vlaenderen(3), Oldrich Nedved(10), Hans Peter Ravn(11), Jean-Claude Gregoire(7), Jean-Christophe de Biseau(7), Dirk Maes(2) (2012) Invasive alien predator causes rapid declines of native European ladybirds. Diversity and Distributions. DOI 10.1111/j.1472-4642.2012.00883.x.

(1) Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, UK; (2) Research Institute for Nature and Forest (INBO), Belgium; (3) CABI Europe-Switzerland; (4) Universite Catholique de Louvain,  Belgium; (5) Anglia Ruskin University, UK; (6) Centre Wallon de Recherches Agronomiques, Belgium; (7) Université Libre de Bruxelles, Belgium; (8) Clifton College, UK; (9) University of Fribourg, Switzerland; (10) University of South Bohemia, Czech Republic; (11) University of Copenhagen, Denmark.

Distribution data was collated largely through public participatory surveys. In Britain, a Coccinellidae Recording Scheme has been run through the Biological Records Centre at the Centre for Ecology and Hydrology since 1964 with an online survey launched in 2005. In Belgium, the Coccinellidae Recording Scheme has been active since 1999 with an online survey; however, ad hoc earlier records exist and were included in analyses. The Britain and Belgium databases contain 89,994 and 67,561 observations, respectively. All records used in the analyses were verified by a recognized expert.

Ladybird abundance data were collected using systematic fortnightly surveys in Brussels (Belgium) during spring 2003, 2005 and 2008, in lime and sycamore trees in 12 urban localities (parks, avenues and roadsides). Surveys at four sites in Cambridgeshire (Britain) and 15 sites in north-western Switzerland span 2006–2010: each site was surveyed 7–9 times per year between April and October. All Cambridgeshire sites were in suburban locations and consisted primarily of deciduous trees; Swiss sites were 50m sections of mixed deciduous hedges. In all countries, surveys were conducted using standard sampling methods including tree beating and sweeping netting Adults of all ladybirds were counted and identified before being released on-site.

The researchers used generalized linear mixed-effects models (GLMMs) to assess the distribution trends of eight conspicuous and historically widespread and common species of ladybird within Belgium and Britain before and after the arrival of the Harlequin ladybird. 

A non-native species (= alien species) is a species introduced (i.e. by human action) outside its natural past or present distribution as defined by the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD). 

Invasive non-native species (INNS) (= invasive alien species or IAS) - An invasive non-native species is a non-native species that has the ability to spread causing damage to the environment, the economy, our health or the way we live.

Funding: The study was primarily funded by the NERC Centre for Ecology & Hydrology and the Joint Nature Conservation Committee. The development of the online surveys in Britain was in part through funding received from the Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs. Natuurpunt and Natagora provided the online encoded records of ladybirds in Belgium. Research in Switzerland was funded by a grant from the Swiss Federal Office for the Environment and the EU FP6 project ALARM.

Science areas: 

Primary Issues: