A new study involving scientists from the University of York, the NERC Centre for Ecology & Hydrology (CEH) and Butterfly Conservation has shown how a butterfly has changed its diet, and consequently has expanded northwards rapidly in response to climate change.
The findings were published this week in the journal Science.
Historically, the Brown Argus butterfly (Aricia agestis) was largely restricted to a single plant species, the Common rockrose (Helianthemum nummularium). But the researchers found that warmer summers have allowed it to complete its life cycle by eating wild Geranium plants. Because the Geraniums are widespread in the British countryside, this change in diet has allowed the butterfly to expand its range in Britain at a surprisingly rapid rate.
Over the past 20 years, the Brown Argus has spread northwards by around 79 kilometres and has become common in the countryside in much of southern England.
Lead author Rachel Pateman, a PhD student with the University of York and the Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, said, "Many species are shifting their distributions northwards as the climate warms, but this previously scarce species has surprised everyone by moving its range at over twice the average rate.”
Co-author David Roy, from the Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, said: “The change in diet represents a change to the interactions between species – in this case between a butterfly and the plants that its caterpillars eat – caused by climate warming. Changes to the interactions between species are often predicted to alter the rate at which species shift their distribution in response to climate change, and now we have demonstrated this in nature.”
In the 1980s the butterfly was considered scarce in Britain, with populations undergoing continued decline but it has subsequently undergone a dramatic reversal of fortune. The team put this down to the effect of climate on the ability of the butterfly to use additional food plant species.
The caterpillars were mainly confined to Rockrose plants growing on the chalk hills of southern England, but the use of plant species in the Geranium family has increased as summer temperatures have increased. Wild Geraniums are suitable food plants for the caterpillars in warm years, but not in colder summers. This seems to be because the plants grow in different places, which provide different microclimates. Common Rockrose is found mainly on hot south-facing slopes, where the butterfly can complete its life cycle even in cool summers. This is not the case for the Geraniums and so they only become suitable for the butterfly when summers are warm.
Co-author Richard Fox, from the charity Butterfly Conservation, said: “It is important that we understand how and why species are responding to climate change. Such research would not be possible without the thousands of records of butterflies our dedicated volunteers have collected over many decades, which have allowed us to detect these long term changes.”
Rachel Pateman said: “This study has highlighted that species do not respond to climate change in isolation, and that climate change affects how species interact with one another. In the case of the Brown Argus butterfly, changes in interactions with its food plants have helped it to respond to climate change very rapidly. However, changes to interactions may hinder other species, potentially putting them at risk of extinction.”
Co-author Professor Jane Hill, of the Department of Biology at the University of York, said: “There will be winners and losers from climate change. It is important that we begin to understand how the complex interactions between species affect their ability to adapt to climate change so we can identify those that might be at risk and where to focus conservation efforts.”
The study was funded by the Natural Environment Research Council.
The paper ‘Temperature-dependent alterations in host use drive rapid range expansion in a butterfly’ by Rachel M. Pateman, Jane K. Hill, David B. Roy, Richard Fox and Chris D. Thomas is published in Science. Doi: 10.1126/science.1216980
The University of York issued a press release for this story.